Official discussion page for Keeper of the Lost Cities!
I hear you. Many people have been asking for it, so at long last, here it is!
You may also like
BlogClan Holiday Gift Exchange 2024: Your Gifts!
Thank you so much to everyone who participated in this year’s gift exchange! As always, your creations were absolutely wonderful and you never fail to blow me away with your talent and creativity! To find your name in...
Goldenfawn
[Dec] End of Year Update
Okay, so this post is a little later than what I would’ve wanted, but I’ve had a busy week 😛 I’m also a little tired, so, only one cat pic this time 😛 You’re getting plenty from Cadvent, anyway...
The Blog Monthly – Seventh Edition
The seventh edition of the Blog Monthly is here – written by Lil, fresh off the printing press Hello, everyone!! The Blog Monthly is back and better than ever! I hope you all love this edition, in my opinion it is one...
🤍🪷 Lilybreeze 🪷🤍
✧˖°🍾⋆˙⟡ pineblossom (she/her) 🦢💫🩰 what are you doing new year's eve? 🌨️🧸🕯️mentor to skyshimmer! 🌲⋆✴︎˚｡⋆
Turning Survivors Into Warriors (Part Two) by Honeyjade
Honeyjade gives warrior names and Warrior Cats match-ups to more characters from Survivors.
Fan Articles
⨺⃝🏳️🌈🏴☠️Jasminepaw/song the Pirate Queen🏴☠️ Jaz, Jazzy, Sienna⨺⃝
Latest Art
More BlogClan Art
Who would you save –
Tam or Keefe?
Maruca or Stina?
Sophie or Linh?
Biana or Fitz?
Edaline or Grady?
Della or Alden?
Jensi or Marella?
Elwin or Livvy?
My answers:
Tam
Maruca
Sophie
Biana
Edaline
Della
Jensi
Elwin
Tam or Keefe? Keefe Tam is weird and rude and just…shadey. Not trying to make fun of him or anything, that’s just the way it is.
Maruca or Stina? Maruca
Sophie or Linh? Sophie — Even though I love Linh so much too!
Biana or Fitz? Biana
Edaline or Grady? Edaline
Della or Alden? Alden
Jensi or Marella? Jensi
Elwin or Livvy? So hard … I think Elwin
KEEFE I LOVE HIM (but I love Tam to 😀)
Maruca (Stina sucks)
Agh I don’t know
Biana (I hate Fitz)
Edaline (I honestly don’t really know, but me like Edaline better)
Della
Ahh don’t make me choose
Elwin
😀
Keefe
Maruca
Sophie (these are so hard bro >.<)
Biana
BROSKI NO- uh- ah- EDALINE.
Della
uhhhh…. Jensi??
Elwin
Dang that was difficult 🙁
Keefe
Marucca
Sophie
BIANA 100%
Edaline
Della
Jensi
Elwin
Keefe <33 But Tam is also awesome!!
Maruca, tho I also like Stina :))
Linh :3
Biana!
Edaline
Della
Marella
This one is harddd uhhh Elwin
(Everyone’s saying Jensi and I feel like something happened with him in Stellarlune and I haven’t read it yet… :>
Keefe (sorry Tam)
Stina (whoa, calm down Stina haters out there)
Sophie
Fitz (Stop booing at me okay? I don’t like him, but he keeps things interesting)
Edaline
Alden
Jensi
Elwin (he’s one of my favorites)
Keefe
Maruca (But I also like Stina!)
Linh
Biana!
Edaline
Della!
Marella (but also Jensi…)
Elwin?
That was so hard T^T
Keefe
Maruca
SOPHIE <3
Biana
Edaline, I don't like Grady all that much
Della
Jensi
Elwin <33
KEEFE
Stina
Sophie
Biana
Edaline
Della
Marella
Elwin
1. Tam is awesome, but Keefe is better, so Keefe.
2. Maruca. I don’t know much about her, but I despise Stina. Despite her “change” she’s still rude and mean.
3. Linh. Sophie is great and all, but…you know. Linh is really kind and innocent and great in general.
4. Ugh I can’t choose. I know everyone’s on about how Fitz is arrogant and rude and has anger issues, which he does, but he’s still caring nonetheless. And Biana’s a great friend, but she was mean for no reason and pretended to be Sophie’s friend at the beginning of the 1st book.
5. Edaline. Grady’s awesome, but he’s pushing Sophie toward Dex and away from Fitz and Keefe, in the complete wrong direction, for literally no reason. Even Edaline has told him to stop, but he won’t.
6. Della. Alden’s just not a likable character…I suspect he is or will turn evil at some point.
7. AAAAAH I dunno….Jensi? I don’t really have a reason, I just feel kinda sorry for him.
8. Elwin. Livvy’s great, but Elwin is the literal best. How can you not like a guy with animal pajamas and heaps of stuffed animals that he gives out at random?
So, if StarClan, the Dark Forest, or just becoming a ghost (so-so people) existed in KotLC, where would you put:
Fitz?
Sophie?
Keefe?
Stina?
Dex?
Biana?
Vespera?
Lady Gisela?
Lord Cassius?
Jolie?
Fintan?
The Councillors?
The Black Swan Collective?
Brant?
Edaline?
Grady?
My answers:
Fitz – Dark Forest
Sophie – StarClan
Keefe – StarClan
Stina – Ghost
Dex – StarClan
Biana – StarClan
Vespera – Bad ghost
Lady Gisela – Dark Forest
Lord Cassius – Ghost
Jolie – Good ghost
Fintan – Bad ghost
The Councillors – Ghosts (some good ghosts, some regular ghosts, some bad ghosts)
The Black Swan Collective – Good ghosts (I don’t understand their disguises. They all have to trust each other, but they won’t trust anyone enough to reveal their true selves!)
Brant – Bad ghost
Edaline – StarClan or really really really good ghost
Grady – StarClan or really good ghost
Whew. That was a lot 😛
Fitz – StarClan
Sophie – StarClan
Keefe – StarClan
Stina – StarClan
Dex – StarClan
Biana – StarClan
Vespera – she gives me the ghost vibes 😛
Lady Gisela – The Dark Forest (she should totally be leader too)
Lord Cassius – ugh StarClan but I would totally put him in the Dark Forest if I had good enough reasons
Jolie – StarClan
Fintan – ghost…
The Councillors – I so want to put them in the Dark Forest but StarClan ig
The Black Swan Collective – StarClan
Brant – The Dark Forest
Edaline – StarClan
Grady – StarClan
Fitz doesn’t deserve StarClan >:0 /hj
I mean, I don’t like him but he hasn’t done anything wrong that would make him deserve StarClan other than being extremely annoying and being a jerk and okay maybe he deserves the Dark Forest 😛
He really hasn’t done anything wrong. Sure, he was a jerk in Exile, but he has anger issues that no one’s helping him with. Besides, his FATHER was BROKEN. And he’s a good guy. He’s caring and sweet and does care about Sophie just as much as Keefe does. Sophie probably trusts him more than Keefe. But to each their own.
Fitz- Dark Forest im sorry
Sophie-Starclan
Keefe-Starclan
Stina-Ghost
Dex-Starclan
Biana-Starclan
Vespera-Dark Forest
Lady Gisela-She would probably get into starclan but deserve the Dark Forest 😛
Lord Cassius-Ghost
Jolie-Starclan
Fintan-Dark Forest
The Councillors-Half in the Dark Forest, half Ghosts, One or Two in Starclan
The Black Swan Collective-Starclan
Brant-Dark Forest
Edaline-Starclan
Grady-Starclan
Fitz – StarClan, even though he’s mean he’s still a good person
Sophie – StarClan
Keefe – Ghost
Stina – Ghost
Dex – STARCLAN
Biana – StarClan
Vespera – Dark Forest
Lady Gisela – DARK FOREST 100000%
Lord Cassius – Ghost
Jolie – StarClan
Fintan – Dark Forest
The Councillors – Most ghosts, some StarClan
The Black Swan Collective – StarClan
Brant – Dark Forest
Edaline – StarClan
Grady – StarClan
I’m not too far into the series, so don’t mind my answers! 😛
Fitz? Ghost
Sophie? StarClan
Keefe? OMG STARCLAN
Stina? Ghost
Dex? StarClan
Biana? StarClan
Vespera? Not there yet!
Lady Gisela? Ehh-DF (she gives me DF leader vibes)
Lord Cassius? Ghost
Jolie? StarClan!!!
Fintan? Ugh- I hate him. DF
The Councillors? Ghosts
The Black Swan Collective? Ghosts
Brant? DF
Edaline? StarClan
Grady? StarClan
Fitz? StarClan
Sophie? StarClan
Keefe? Really really really good ghost or StarClan
Stina? I gotta go with StarClan here
Dex? StarClan
Biana? StarClan
Vespera? Dark Forest
Lady Gisela? DF
Lord Cassius? StarClan
Jolie? StarClan
Fintan? Ghost
The Councillors? DF
The Black Swan Collective? StarClan
Brant? Ghost
Edaline? StarClan
Grady? Ghost
Opinions on Dexiana and Tiana and why? I’m still struggling on figuring out which ship I like better 😛
Dexiana – I LOVE THIS SHIP!!!!!! They’re so cute together and what once was a jealousy/hate relationship has turned into this beautiful thing (I mean the jealousy/hate coming from Dex). And, while they have many differences, they also have similarities – both are creative in their own ways (Biana through fashion and Dex through technology), both are willing to do anything for their friends and the greater good, and both of them are just overall really good characters with awesome and unique personalities.
Tiana – I hate this ship with a quiet but BURNING PASSION. Like – what?! Who came up with this?!? No offense to the people who ship this, but – what the heck are you thinking?! I know people ship them because of their polar opposite personalities, with Tam being this emo punk boy and Biana being this bright, sparkles-loving girl, but this is exactly why I don’t ship them. They are just too different. Also, they have very few interactions and therefore, what would they see in each other? Tam is not Biana’s type, and Biana is not Tam’s type.
Another reason I don’t ship them is because of something in Stellarlune, but I know you haven’t read that yet so I’ll keep that one to myself for now.
I ship Tarella and i agree strongly with this 😛
Thank you for not spoiling anything for me I think Stellarlune is coming from my library in a few days so I’ll read it soon >:D
No problem 🙂
DEXIANA <33
Unpopular KotLC Opinion Time!
– I strongly dislike Keefe (ask me why, I wrote a rant about this)
– I strongly dislike Linh (ask me, I dare you)
– I don’t ship Tiana (I know most people here don’t ship it, but the majority of people I’ve met do)
– I like Councillor Oralie (Fight me)
– I actually really like Jensi and don’t understand why some people hate him
What are your unpopular opinions?
I agree with all except the first
Oh also
-I shipped Beefe (Biana-Keefe) pre-book 4
-I strongly dislike Vespera as a character she is very poor written
-Fintan is overrated
-Jensi is adorable and i love him yes
-Councillor Oralie was sucked into this problem shes a good person
… why do you dislike Linh?
(😛)
Because of Stellarlune (You’ll see soon…)
Uh oh :O
I see why now T^T (and I’ve only read the first part of the book so I’m scared)
Yeah…. :/
– I like Stina (fight me…)
– I also don’t like Linh and started disliking her even before Stellarlune
– I also don’t ship Tiana
– Marella is underrated (Marella forever :D)
– Gisela and Vespera kind of failed as characters
Dex is overrated
Tiana is bad
Jensi is amazing
Sophie is overrated
Marella is underrated
I JUST FOUND SMTH OUT
Paper is being made less and less from wood
its being made from cotton and linen
THATS HOW THE ELVES MAKE IT
MY SANITY IS SAVED NOW
*Le gasp*
The mystery has been solved! (Cotton is also a plant though, so they probably just make it from linen)
Well cotton can be harvested without killing the plant
like fruit
mE bEiNg SlEeP dEpRiVeD
How is your pfp an oval????
Honestly I have no idea, it might be the size of the png?
WHAT HECK YEAH >:D
Can’t the elves use wood…?
No, because it involves killing trees and elves do not stand for it
I LOVE KotLC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hooray! Welcome to our
culthappy little discussion page!Yesss hellooo >:DDD
Would you rather? Ship Tam x Biana or Dex x Biana?
DEXIANA FOR LIFE
I HATE TIANA (No offense to the people that ship them)
Uhhhh… I literally cannot choose :> I just got Stellarlune so once I finish reading I’ll judge 🙂
Biana for life <3
…?
Dexiana!
DEXIANA IS SOOO CUTE!!! Tiana is just a little boring for me, sorry for those that ship it:/
Opinions on Councillor Oralie and why?
(I personally like her, I just want to know your opinions 😀)
I like her and think that she was put in a very difficult situation and could have made some better choices by trying to tell Sophie, MAYBE, I don’t know if that would have helped, but I do like her and think that she doesn’t deserve the hate she gets.
yesss <3
Unrelated, but I love their quote in your name! (Gravity Falls is amazing!) 😀
Thanks Echo! I like it too, although I haven’t finished it yet 😀
She’s weird I’m neutral on her, I used to really like her but now she’s just meh
I am finding myself disliking her more and more now because of Stellarlune lol so now I’m pretty neutral :’)
I don’t LIKE her but she’s one of the good guys so I don’t know what to think
I’m neutral on her overall, since there’s parts about her I like and dislike 🙂
I don’t like her but I don’t hate her.
I like her and think that Sophie is totally overreacting to what Oralie did. I mean, Oralie really wanted a child of her own and when she saw her chance, she wanted it. Would she have just gone on without any descendants, not being able to see her child grow and make accomplishments? I really just feel sorry for her.
What’s your opinion on Stina? I personally like her and think she doesn’t deserve as much hate 🙂
Eh, she’s ok, but I don’t really think she adds much to the plot
Well… I liked her a lot more than I used to in Legacy but now that I’m reading Stellarlune… ehhh 🙂
She’s just there.
She exists
Yeah she just exists 😛
Do you guys ever get annoyed with Mr. Forkle? I know that I do a lottt >:)
Yes 😛
Yes all the timeee
I get annoyed at ALL the adults in KotLC 😛
Definitely haha
I’m always annoyed with him 😀
Thoughts on chapter 42?
I am a hardcore sokeefe fan so I loved it, what about you?
Oof YES
Yes I read it like, a gazillion times until it got too mushy lol
It’s ok. I used to love it and it’s a great chapter and FINALLY, FINALLY FINALLY FINALLY, we got SoKeefe
I’m really close to reading it and since I have a library book it is so wrinkled in that part of the book XD
Theories about Elysian? Personally I think Elysian is a human who was experimented on by Vespera and they got immortality and the ability to turn off powers and they’d been exiled and they created Elysian Fields for other humans like them
Also I think Elysian will become the new villain and the Black Swan and the Neverseen will team up against them
I think that Keefe’s and Elysian’s powers are connected – Keefe can make people do whatever he wants by just saying the right word, and Elysian can turn off peoples’ abilities – maybe there’s a word, or a mental command, that can do that.
Somebody please give me clean and intresting Kotlc fan fiction because all those on Wattpad are either too boring or say inappropriate things😑
Ikr! Tbh I have no clue why a lot of them are like that for middle grade fiction. It’s really annoying.
OOO! OOO! I GOT ONE!!!! I’m currently writing it and it is not about a ship, actually – it’s about what I would do if I got teleported into the first book of the series.
Here’s the link if you want to read it, it’s slow-in-progress but I’m working on it:
https://www.quotev.com/story/15593838/What-I-would-do-if-I-was-Teleported-to-the-Lost-Cities-Book-1/1
I’m planning on making one sometime