Official discussion page for Keeper of the Lost Cities!
I hear you. Many people have been asking for it, so at long last, here it is!
You may also like
BlogClan Holiday Gift Exchange 2024: Your Gifts!
Thank you so much to everyone who participated in this year’s gift exchange! As always, your creations were absolutely wonderful and you never fail to blow me away with your talent and creativity! To find your name in...
Goldenfawn
[Dec] End of Year Update
Okay, so this post is a little later than what I would’ve wanted, but I’ve had a busy week 😛 I’m also a little tired, so, only one cat pic this time 😛 You’re getting plenty from Cadvent, anyway...
The Blog Monthly – Seventh Edition
The seventh edition of the Blog Monthly is here – written by Lil, fresh off the printing press Hello, everyone!! The Blog Monthly is back and better than ever! I hope you all love this edition, in my opinion it is one...
🤍🪷 Lilybreeze 🪷🤍
✧˖°🍾⋆˙⟡ pineblossom (she/her) 🦢💫🩰 what are you doing new year's eve? 🌨️🧸🕯️mentor to skyshimmer! 🌲⋆✴︎˚｡⋆![[a simplistic full-body design of Millie wearing a collar]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/millie-shyranno-385x300.png)
Fan Articles![[Graystripe sits while Feathertail steps around him. Stormkit and Featherkit are playing by their side]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/graystripe-silverstream-stormfur-feathertail-385x300.png)
![[cut-out of Leopardstar from a coloured panel of Graystripe's Adventure, sitting down and looking to her right]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Leopardstar.GA_-250x300.png)
Unpopular thoughts of mine by Frostclaw
Frostclaw shares various opinions they have about the series.
Latest Art
More BlogClan Art
HIHI DAIS <333
As you know, I haven't read KotLC yet, but I will soon! It sounds really good :))
You should! I can’t remember a lot of it, but I have read the whole series and I loved it 😛
*stalks across several creaky floorboards and slowly enters the dusty, barren discussion page*
EVERYBODY EVERYBODY THIS IS IMPORTANT THE KOTLC MOVIE HAS JUST BEEN CONFIRMED IT’S GONNA BE PRODUCED BY WARNER BROS. I AM LITERALLY JUMPING UP AND DOWN WITH EXCITEMENT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!- 😀
Okay, anyways, who y’all think Sophie’s dad is??? 😀 I seriously think it’s Fintan
Byeeeeeeeeeeee 🙂
definitely Elwin *nods confidently* but Fintan is an interesting theory?
REALLY!!!! How have I not heard about thisssss
HALLELUJAH
IKR IM SO EXCITED AAAAA
Elwin definitely
That’s so cool!!! :O
And I think Sophie’s dad is Tiergan! He specifically came back from retirement to train her in telepathy, he gave her a speech in the first book about her worth that reads differently if you look at it through viewing him as her father, and he’s always been there for her and offered a special level of support and advice. He is also a blond Telepath, like Sophie is!
Plus, “Alenefar,” his last name, means “single father” in Norwegian :O
That’s a solid point, except for one thing… Mr. Forkle specifically told Sophie that her parents didn’t have the same ability/abilities as her, and while he could be lying, MASSIVE SPOILERS FOR LEGACY it was true with Oralie.
Ooh, that’s a very good point, I had forgotten about that. Perhaps Tiergan’s last name could be a reference to how he’s a ‘single father’ to Wylie. In that case, I think I’m probably stuck between Fintan, Elwin, and maybe Prentice as her father!
Cool! I’m torn between Brant and Elwin
Yeah, I’m torn between everyone now! So excited to see who it is :O
*gasps* Fintan? whyyyeeyyyyyyyyy???!
People made good points about him 😛 I’ll just be lying in wait to see who it is at this point 😛
SPOILERS! SPOILERS!
[Spoiler alert: You have to have read all the books or this is a MASSIVE spoiler]
It’s not Fintan or Prentice, or Brant or Tiergan.
Oh gosh, really?? Don’t tell me anymore, I gotta get to the book now 😛 /lh
WAIT if Mr Forkle told Sophie that her parents didn’t have the same ability/abilities as her then that means KENRIC CAN’T BE SOPHIE’S FATHER BECAUSE HE WAS A TELEPATH.
Sooooo true actuallyyyy!
Prentice. Isn’t it obvious?!!! /lh
I honestly have no idea 😛
OH MY GOD YAY THATS SO EXCITING
No idea 😛 To be honest with you, I don’t remember much of the series 😭 Fintan is a great theory :O
NO WAY A KOTLC MOVIE?!?!?!
WHY HAS NO ONE MENTIONED THIS BEFOOOREE 🤯🤯🤯
When is it coming out?!? omg I’m so excited
Also I agree!!! I think Sophie’s father is either Fintan, Tiergan or Elwin (idk why but he has the caring doctor daddy vibes lol)
Me whenever Keefe even just exists in a scene: *pulls a Silveny*
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE!!
KEEFE
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE
KEEFE! KEEFE! KEEFE!
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE
KEEFE KEEFE KEEFE
I started reading Percy Jackson and now I forget what happens in kotlc and now I have to re-read it again 😛
Why is that soooo relatable though-
I’ve been meaning to finish Lodestar but I just can’t find the time and that makes me so sad oefneofnef 😭
omsc the ending of lodestar-
ikr-
I have read the entirety of KOTLC and have forgotten everything, so I have to reread them too 😛
Ooft, it has been sooooooo long since I’ve been here!!!! 🤣😅😅 Anyways, updates!!!:
– book 10 has been stalled another year 😔 BUTTTTT, WE’RE GETTING A BOOK 9.5!!!!!!!!!! AND IT’S ENTIRELY FROM KEEFE’S POINT OF VIEW!!!!!!!!!!! 🤯🤩🤩🤩😁😁😁😄😄😄
– book 9.5 is called Unraveled, and is basically the what Keefe was doing during his time in the Forbidden Cities during Stellarlune!!!!!!!!
– the first line of 9.5 is “Okay. What now?”
– SHANNON IS GOING TO REVEAL KEEFE’S MIDDLE NAME IT IS CONFIRMED!!!!!!!
– Keefe is gonna get a friend fox 😃 idk how this is relavent, but it is
– it’s out November 12!!!!!
– all the information I’m giving you is canon and has been posted on Shannon Messenger’s Instagram 😀
I AM SO EXCITED!!!!!!!!! 😀 😀 😀 Enjoy, everyone, and have an AWESOME day/morning/afternoon/evening/night wherever and whenever you are!!!!!!! Sia (I know it’s supposed to be cya but… 😝)
WAIT WHAT WE FIND OUT HIS MIDDLE NAME AHHHH IT’S SO WORTH IT NOW AHHHHHHHH
WAIT WE FIND OUT HIS MIDDLE NAME?? YES
I think it’s Cassius 😛
*crosses fingers that we’ll figure out what the great gulon incident is*
*also crosses fingers*
I think it’s Cassius as well, but this is Shannon Messenger, we never know… ._.
yeah it could be something totally random 😛
*crosses all fingers*
But wouldn’t that be kinda weird considering he’s Keefe’s father?
I only have a not it list which consistes of:
Tiergan probs not
Brontë
I can’t remember the rest except for Prentice because it’s too obvious and Cassius because…you know
But this is Shannon so who knows
In Unlocked, isn’t his middle name covered with the words “I’m not your legacy boy” or something? I think maybe it’s Gisela or Minette. (Minette is Lady Gisela’s middle name.) Or Cassius. I also read a fanfiction where Ro reveals Keefe’s middle name and it’s Bobert. I THINK it’s Sleepover Shenanigans by Kathe on Quotev, but it has a lot of chapters and I’m too lazy to look at them all. (A random fact: Before I read Nightfall, I thought Ro was a goblin.)
I still remember the moment I realised I was Team Keefe I was immediately like forget Fitz
Keefe just getting a fox friend is just like💕it’s too cuteee
Yesssss 😀 Before Stellarlune was released I always wanted Keefe to befriend some sort of animal in the Forbidden Cities 😀 and now he gets a friend fox and rnsxetjymysx it’s adorable 😀
AAHHHH I’M SO EXCITED!!!
Thank you for telling us!
It was postponed into december now 🙁
Okay I’m just going to open Pandora’s box here
What’s everyone’s opinion on Oralie?
Personally she’s gone back to neutral for me
Neutral 😀 honestly no opinion on her right now
I don’t like her because she’s such a Mary Sue and has no personality. aLso she always agree with everyone and says all these nice thins but when it’s time to actually put whatever into action she just watches.
she fixed up Exillium!
I like her, she’s WAY better than the rest of the council sooo
She’s nice :))
she’s fine, she hasn’t done anything terrible, but she has done a lot of good. she simply isn’t that interesting lol
idk why Sophie hates her though it never made sense to me
Well every single freaking metting with Sophie Oralie lied to Sophie and hid that she was her mother. I’d understand that, even if she was ordered to keep it secret. If she loved Sophie that much she would’ve told her. Oh and maybe not have let Sophie be experimented on by the Black Swan, and and stuff but then we wouldn’t have the series
Considering the fact I cannot remember most of the books for the life of me, I’ll say neutral! I do remember liking her, though 🙂 So maybe neutral leaning toward like, instead of neutral leaning toward dislike 🙂
So one of my classmates awhile ago told me that if you jumped off a skyscraper, you would have approximately 2.63 seconds before you hit the ground (Yes I asked that smack in the middle of science class). So I just realized that if Sophie jumps out of the window on the fourth floor of Havenfield and then levitates idk how much, she’d have just about that am}amount of time, if not less, to teleport.
I would NEVER be able to do that!
OMG I never thought about that-
2.63 seconds?!?! You’d probably have to take away 1 second for the reaction time, making it 1.63 seconds, and then another 1 second for Sophie to actually start teleporting-
0.63 seconds. Hades I can’t even-
Woah. My brain can’t even process that-
Waiiit that never crossed my mind before! I guess it always seemed like it took longer in the books?? That’s insane, I just know I would hesitate and then die 😭
EVERYONE EVERYONE EVERYONE-
GOOD NEWS AND BAD NEWS
FIRST, UNRAVELED HAS BEEN DELAYED DUE TO PUBLISHING INSANITY 😭😭😭 DECEMBER 3RD NOW. THREE WEEKS LATER THAN WE FIRST THOUGHT
BUT
BUT
SHANNON MESSENGER HAS ANNOUNCED THAT THERE’S GOING TO BE A BONUS CHAPTER (KEEFE’S POV) IN ALL THE COPIES. PAPERACK, HARDCOVER, EXCLUSIVES- ALL OF THEM
AND GUESS WHAT IT IS
(hint : it was in Stellarlune, most of all of us were super hyped when we read it, it starts with a 4 and ends with a 2…)
I’ll update ya’ll when more info is released!!!!!!!! 😀 😀
AAAAAAAAA YESYESYESYES KEEFEEEEE
thank you for giving me motivation to continue reading Lodestar haha 😛
OKAY IM PUTTING DECEMBER 3RD ON MY CALENDER
OMG YES CHAPTER 42 🎉🎉✨️
OMG NO WAY *implodes*
Oh my god, we’re getting Keefe’s POV during CHAPTER 42???
As a non-Sokeefe shipper, I’m kind of hoping its different from what we expected and that Keefe proves me right that he’s a selfish brat, so I won’t be the one with the unpopular oppinion.
Ok I have a huge theory on who Sophie’s Dad is. I am 100000% sure that it is KENRIC. The dead counselor that was not so secretly in love with Oralie who is (HUGE SPOILER IS AHEAD STOP READING THIS NOW IF YOU HAVE NOT FINISHED STELLARLUNE!) Sophie’s Mom! And in one of the books Sophie mentioned that Kenric would be HEARTBROKEN if Oralie was her mother! But what if Kenric was Sophie’s father and had NO IDEA. Oralie could have hid her pregnancy using some weird elixir from Slurps and Burps. But there is also a chance Kenric DID know he was Sophies father and wouldn’t that explain why he was so nice to her when OTHER councilors *glares at Bronte* weren’t? That’s just my theory guys tell me what you think.
This is a really good theory, wow!!! :O
No, it’s not, because Forkle said they Sophie’s parents didn’t know each other.
Love the theory, but I have to agree with Rosefern her 🙂
I think Forkle could have easily lied to protect this secret and also couldn’t ORALIE have lied when she gave Sophie to the black swan to protect Kenric? Although it IS just a theory. Thanks for the feed back, Rosefern! I might have to double check this theory with a re-read. 😛 It would help if the author made a novella in Oralie’s perspective about Sophie.
I think Forkle could have easily lied to protect this secret and also couldn’t ORALIE have lied when she gave Sophie to the black swan to protect Kenric? Although it IS just a theory. Thanks for the feed back, Rosefern! I might have to double check this theory with a re-read. 😛 It would help if the author made a novella in Oralie’s perspective about Sophie. 🤔
Yeah it would. You wanna hear my out-of-this-world thory on Sophie’s biological dad.
One of the Forkles could easily be it because when one of them said no it wouldn’t be a lie because it was the other one, or maybe he’s just really good at lying to Empaths, I really don’t think he would do that though, it’s just a guess lol
Ooh sounds interesting!! I’ll look into it when it isn’t 12am… (aka not right now)
it’s a great theory, but Forkle said they didn’t know each other. He could have lied, sure, but i’m not sure he would have for this. I think it’s Elwin
Oooooooh interesting!!! I can’t wait to find out who Sophie’s dad is!
Mr. Forkle told her that her parents didn’t know each other or have the same ability/abilities as her. Kenric and Sophie are both Telepaths. Kenric is not Sophie’s father.
*WARNING SPOILERS FOR STELLARLUNE*
I have a theory. What if the person Kenric mentions in one of the memories isn’t Vespera but Elysian? I’m very confident that I’m right.
*WARNING SPOILERS FOR STELLARLUNE*
I have a theory. What if the person Kenric mentions in one of the memories isn’t Vespera but Elysian? I’m very confident that I’m right. Who’s excited for book 10!
Wait Vespera is that villain right? And then who is Elysian? I swear I’ve read the books ya’ll, it’s just been awhile 😭
hmm don’t remember that 😛 BUT YES SO EXCITED (its book 9.5 now tho :P)
hello! I was thinking of starting to read this series! can someone give me basics of what this is about? just so I have the basic idea of this series
(Oh my god, this has just made me realize how crusty my memory of this series is. Someone send help-)
So the series is about this girl, who starts off thinking she is a normal human like you and me. But she’s always been different, and eventually, she ends up discovering she’s an elf and moves to their magical kingdom. She makes friends, blah blah, but there’s this evil group that needs to be stopped, and so many plot twists and secrets that come to light, and there’s romance, and it’s just amazing!!!
I have described it terribly, I’m sorry 😛😭 Someone else step in and help, please :’P
Twelve-year-old Sophie Foster has a secret. She is a Telepath, and has a unique ability to hear the thoughts of everyone else around her – something that she’s never known how to explain, and has made her an outcast, even in her own family. But everything changes the day she meets Fitz, a mysterious boy who appears out of nowhere and also reads minds. She discovers there’s somewhere she does belong, and staying where she is will put her in grave danger. In the blink of an eye, Sophie is forced to leave behind everything and start a new life in a place that is vastly different from her own. Sophie has new rules and skills to learn, and not everyone is thrilled with her “homecoming.” There are secrets buried deep in Sophie’s memory, secrets that other people desperately want. Would even kill for . . .
basically this random fiction book series abt a 12 year old girl who is so cool and has powers blah blah blah she’s suddenly an elf 😀
sorry this is terrible XD