Is Firestar a good character? by Ashpool

Ashpool shares their thoughts on Firestar.

Hello there! I’m Ashpool! This is my first blog post! I’ll be debating on whether Firestar is actually a good character!
Ok, let’s get going!

I know a lot of Warriors lovers, and most of them say their favorite warrior is Firestar, but some people disagree and say he’s to overrated! Each of them pointed out things to me, so I’ll review them:

In defense for Firestar

Firestar saved all the clans and is the main character in the first series! It’s hard not to like the main character, and he is an interesting cat! Besides, he is one of the legendary leaders of ThunderClan! He gave up his life against the dark forest, and that’s pretty important. Also, he was part of at least two prophecies! He killed Tigerstar once also and led the clans into battle to defeat Scourge. He has an interesting personality and he’s really great! And without him, his descendants, mainly the three and Ivypool and Hollyleaf, wouldn’t exist and then the Dark Forest would have definitely won. Dovewing never would have gotten the water back also. Firestar also was on the Great Journey and was one of the leaders then.

Against Firestar

Firestar is so overrated. He saves the clans twice and dies in a heroic death. Everyone likes him and talks about him and it’s mostly just because he’s the main character of the first series and was in two prophecies. He thinks he’s soooooooooooo humble, but he really just sticks his nose into every cat’s business! Also, he just falls in love with Spottedleaf like that! And Spottedleaf always helps him from StarClan because she loves him, but she barely even met him! And then, she gives her life for his mate, but again! you barely even knew him, Spottedleaf! He’s not even that good-looking! And you’re always giving him prophecies! It’s a medicine cat’s job to receive prophecies! You’re really just annoying, Firestar!

Well, that’s the end! So, what do you think? Did I do good on my first post or not? And also, is Firestar a good character to you?