We use cookies to optimize our website and our service.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
What’s yall’s opinion on Darktail? I think he was a pretty good villain but I don’t really like the whole Onestar thing.
I think he’s a cool villain
i am surprised how short lived of a villain he was tbh
Anticlimactic. He could have been really great, but… he just died really quickly. I also think he has the personality of a sock. It’s boring and gets lost easily.
What is your opinion on Cherryfall?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!She is pretty meh. She became a stereotypical peppy
villagercat, and she got kind of annoying to read about, especially in The Apprentice’s QuestI like her, but she’s pretty boring
cherry
fall
I don’t really like her. And I was wondering about why in Bramblestar’s Storm she was acting like she liked Stormcloud but then in other books she started liking Bumblestripe?
She likes Bumblestripe??? That’s her great uncle or something like that
What’s your opinion on Molewhisker?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!I like him!
I don’t like him. He annoys me
whiskers of a mole
Good mentor~
What is your opinion on Stormcloud x Cherryfall?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!It’s cute!
seems coral
Eh…
I love them! <3
Cherryfall was so caring when Stormcloud was grieving his brother.
I wish they'd been made canon :')
But I also love them as friends! 😀 Whether romantic or simply friends, they're super sweet together either way.
What is your opinion on Toadstep x Blossomfall?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!it’s a ship!
It’s kind of random… but i guess it would make more sense and/or be cuter than thornxblossom
My favorite Blossomfall ship! They played together as kits, I think she had a crush on him when they were apprentices (or at least her siblings claimed so) and they have similar struggles with their parents ignoring them so they could relate to each other.
https://take.supersurvey.com/poll4649174x4C0144E1-145
Honestly, I like both.
yes
I like both, but if I had to choose, it would be Dovewing!
Douwing but they’re both good
Ivypool!! I’m okay with Dovewing tho 🙂
Doveamazing
Ivy
IVYPOOL FOREVER, DOVEWING WILL ALWAYS BE THE JERK WITH POWERS THAT LEFT HER CLAN FOR THE WORST CAT POSSIBLE, TIGERHEART
Who is your favourite living medicine cat or medicine cat apprentice? Mine is probably Alderheart or Frostpaw
medicine cat :))
Alderheart!
jayfeather
Jayfeather, Frostpaw, Puddleshine… oh and idk why but i like Kestrelflight and whistlepaw!! alderheart’s cool too.
So basically all of them except mothwing. I dont like mothwing
Cinderpelt
(Cinderheart’s alive, right? It counts.)
nope 😛 Cinderheart isn’t a medicine cat and she is her own cat…
Mothwing
Jayfeather 100000000000000% I don’t care that he’s a little overrated I LOVE HIM.
Alderheart, Kestrelflight, Mothwing, & Willowshine not jayboi cuz i hate him
What’s the last book you read?
Not just Warriors, but any book!
I’ve read On This Day in History by James Fell!
A dog psychology book
Squirrelflight’s Hope 😛
some avos one
Ginger Pye
Everblaze!
a guide to pigeons that i got for christmas
The Red Pyramid
Yellowfang’s Secret!😀
I think it was ‘The Boy, the Mole, the Fox & the Horse’ by Charles Mackesy. 🙂
oh my gosh that book is good!
It really is! 🙂
They recently made an animated short based on the book and it aired on TV during Christmas, but I forgot to watch it until I saw your reply. 😛
Onestar’s Confession
A Court of Silver Flames by Sarah J Maas! it was pretty bad imo, don’t read it 😛 (also it’s not appropriate for kids–just a heads up)
Kotlc exile (im reading everblaze rn)
devil within. its a heavy book but i did enjoy it
Sky
The Inheritance Games
Lost Stars!
Keeper of the Lost Cities: Exile! I just got it from my school library today! 😀
Read and finished? Moon RIsing: The Graphic novel.
Read as in haven’t finished but most recently? Ender’s Game.
Good Dog
What is your opinion on Thornclaw?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!I like him ever since I read Flamecloud’s article about him!!
aww I’m glad my article was influencial to you!
He’s ok 🙂
He’s a cool dynamic character
I love Thornclaw! He’s so underrated
patrols
ehh… I don’t hate him but I don’t like how he took a mate so much younger than him and trained in the DF
Thornclaw’s… interesting.
He’s okay in my opinion. I really didn’t like the way he acted in Graystripe’s Vow.
He’s a fine character? I don’t know, honestly :’P
He’s okay, but sometimes was annoying
He would be very interesting if the Erins did something cool with him :p
I think he’s very interesting!
patrol guy!! and more than a patrol guy!! (go read flamflam’s article!)
I like him a lot for some reason 😛
He’s a guy
He is a interesting character, but also a patrol guy 😛
He’s the patrol guy and will forever be the patrol guy. Nothing else.😛
I like him! He deserves more credit <3
I find him at least somewhat interesting. For example, Thornclaw seems to have been influenced by his mentor, Mousefur. They have very simliar political views, which I find very cool. Whether this was unintentional, or a rare stroke of genius continuity by the authors, I just really like that little detail. Plus the article convinced me of his depth. 🙂
I love him, he’s so overlooked
What is your opinion on Sunstar?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!I love him!!! He’s super underrated
Who’s the speedy mod…
ehh he’s fine ig
He’s so underrated and an awesome character <3
Another epic character 😀
yeah
I love him!
He’s a great leader! 😀
He’s a good character 🙂
I really like him! One of the best leaders.
I really like him! He’s a good leader and deserves more recognition
great dude <3
he’s kind of overrated 😛
He’s a cool dude!
I like him a lot and think he’s incredibly underrated!! Though, that’s probably because he’s only in one or two books.
Pretty chill leader. He’s cool. I admire how he was able to take back Sunningrocks without a fight
What is your opinion on Leafpool and Sorreltail’s friendship?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!I like it!
I love it it’s super sweet! I don’t ship them tho i like them as friends
It’s really sweet. I don’t ship them, though.
It’s very sweet <3
yuppp
Favourite Friendship!
I like it, but I like MothxLeaf better 😀
I like it!
I think it’s really sweet!
It’s great!😀 (Sorreltail is my favourite character, so I’m biased!😛)
shoulda gotten more page time
I like it!
they are very nice
They are soo cute together!
I LOVE it!
It’s a real sweet friendship!
I like it! I wish we got to see more of it.
It’s cute! I don’t ship them, but I like it when the character have friends that aren’t there as a plot device. And I love how we still got hints of that friendship in later books.
<3
What is your opinion on Ivypool and Twigbranch’s mentor/apprentice relationship?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!its really great!
I think it’s one of the better ones!
It’s way better that a lot of other ones, I love their dynamic.
yes
It’s awesome! Ivypool was always there for Twigbranch when she was feeling down <3
I think it’s much better than some and it’s pretty cool.
I liked it!
I love it <3
love em!
I love it!! Ivypool was such a supportive mentor! <3
It’s great! Ivypool was so kind to Twigbranch and supportive of her!
Definitely one of the best mentor/apprentice relationships out there <3
What is your opinion on Mousewhisker x Minnowtail?
Hamilton wrote... the other 51!I love it!!!! I want it to be canon
I like it!
I’m pretty neutral on it, it just doesn’t really have any development so there’s not really anything to love or hate.
yes
I love it! It’s healthy in age and I love how Mousewhisker looks up to her
It’s great!😀
I wish it were canon- as disappointed as I am to say this, seeing the background characters actually, well, have a life outside of just being a name and description on the allegiances is always refreshing to see.
neither of them have that much developement, and the ship has less, so I’m pretty indifferent
it’s so cute and one of those things only fans ship and the authors probably have no idea exist 😛
I love that you can make absolutely anything out of them. We need more side character forbidden romances, just like – a few hints sprinkled around. Tbf these guys arent even canon though
I have a very bad memory so I don’t remember anything about them interacting…could someone give me interaction examples?
I know I’m like a old grandma who can’t remember anyone’s name lol 😅
It has to be canon… GIVE ME MOUSEXMINNOW OR GIVE ME DEATH
Uh… this is a thing? Do Mousewhisker and Minnowtail have things in common or meet up? I honestly barely know who these to characters even are XD
They only had like two conversations. I want the LONGING. THE FEELINGS. THE CHEMISTRY!!! And all I really saw was a middle-school level crush.