Fallowpaw rates some canon relationships from the series.
![[Brightheart cuddles into Cloudtail in the forest]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/cloudtail_and_brightheart_by_graypillow_dehg1sf-fullview-1-268x300.jpg)
[Brightheart cuddles into Cloudtail in the forest]
Hellooooo!!! My InTrOs ArE cRiNgY sO I’lL sKiP iT. Let’s just start already! I will say ship or sink, rate the ship out of ten, and explain myself. Here we go!
1. FireSand
Ship or Sink: Sink
My reasons: Simple: Sandstorm hates Firestar. And I know, many people like the enemies to lovers thing, but I think it’s unrealistic and weird. They argue ALL THE TIME in TPB, and who knows, probably also in the later series, but we don’t see it then? But at least their ages are close and I hate both so I don’t feel bad for ’em😛
My rating: 2/10
2. LeafCrow
Ship or Sink: Sink.
My reasons: Crowfeather is mean, annoying and rude, while Leafpool is kind, gentle and wise. I hate him, love her. And this ship was also sooooooooo rushed! First they were like: ‘Ew, I hate you, go away’, and then they were suddenly like: ‘Oh sweetheart, I love you, let’s have kits!’ It was very random and out of nothing, and there’s not a single thing I like about this ship, except they did create Jayfeather and Hollyleaf. And Lionboi but we don’t care about him😛
My rating: 1/10
3. BrightCloud
Ship or Sink: SHIPSHIPSHIPPPP!!!!!!
My reasons: They’re cute, understand each other, stand up for each other, always forgive each other, it’s just such a sweet ship! And yes, they had the Daisy problem, but who cares? Like, all couples have problems sometimes, they aren’t all Mary Sueish like BrackenSorrel, and in the end, they’re always there for each other! Shippyyyyyyyy!!!
My rating: 10/10
4. GraySilver
Ship or Sink: Ship
My reasons: They TRULY loved each other. Graystripe never cared about Millie (in my opinion) but he did care about Silverstream. I love how she saved him, and it was also nice to see the she-cat saving the tom for once, which is very realistic! They cared a lot about their kits too (Graystripe was a jerk to his other three kits) and it was a pretty nice ship! It was rushed tho.
My rating: 7/10
5. StormBrook
Ship or Sink: Sink
My reasons: The Tribe cats are manipulative and I hate them! Stormfur should’ve stayed with the Clans! Brook didn’t help them to escape when Stoneteller kept the sundrownplace cats as prisoners! But I guess the ship isn’t terrible either.
My rating: 4/10
6. BrambleSquirrel
Ship or Sink: Sink
My reasons: Tttttttthhhhhhhhheeeeeeee aaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrggggggggggguuuuuuuuuummmmmmmmeeeeeeeeennnnnnnnnnnntttttttttttttsssssssss! I’m just tired of ’em! And Squirrelflight is an annoying jerk, while Bramblestar neglects his family. Terrible match. And enemies to lovers. I hate that.
My rating: 3/10
So, that was it for today! May the Dark Forest light your path! (I love being evil, right?) Please note that I respect everyone’s opinions and I don’t mean to hurt or offend anybody! Fallowpaw out!
Great article, Fallow!! :>
I do disagree for a few of your points, however. FirexSand had way more development than you mentioned in your article. It wasn’t a ship with the mutual feelings rushed overnight, there was way more that happened that built up to their eventual relationship. Firestar, then Fireheart, saved Sandpaw from falling off the gorge, earning her respect and gratitude.
As for LeafxCrow, I don’t remember that much about the ship’s development, but I don’t think I’d label Crowfeather as a rude and bossy dude and Leafpool as the sweet, kind angel. And then onto StormxBrook, I’m pretty sure Brook never manipulated Stormfur, or tried to force him into staying with the Tribe back in Moonrise. In contrast, she was endlessly loyal to him, and willing to leave her Tribe and the cats she’d grown up with to be with him, to head off into the unknown.
Again, nice article :3
I agree with all of these points 🙂
Great article! But I disagree with most of these (I TOTALLY AGREE ON CLOUDTAIL AND BRIGHTHEART THOUGH THEY ARE SO CUTE AND I LOVE THEM)
I agree with all of these. 😀
Great article! I agree with Seedo 😀 I also don’t think Graystripe was a jerk to Millie’s kits and I’m very sure he really loved her :3 But yeah I totally agree with Bright x Cloud, tho I’m a bit over it! :3
Get BramblexSquirrel outta here, stop arguing! If you sit down and talk, maybe that will fix something?!?! But all they do is ArGuE aRgUe ArGuE!!!!!!!
leafcrow is a litte rushed
Great article. I felt like LeafXCrow was very forced. :/
Good job Fallowsy!
I don’t sandXfire tbh
LeafXCrow is pretty bad
BrightXCloud is my favorite of all time! <3
StormXBrook ig it's pretty cute but yeah 😛
Cool article!
I agree with all of these!
I totally agree with some of your points, but the one about Squirrelflight being a jerk, I mean, your not NECESSARILY wrong, but I am a HUGE Squirrelstar fan, so I have to say no. But everything else was good! I agree that BramblexSquirrel was TERRIBLE. Ashfur could have been better (before TBC).
Great job, though Fallow!
Crystalpaw/mist is out!
I agree with you on most of these. However, StormBrook was a lot more, ah, sweet and loving than you say. Also, BRAMBLESQUIRREL IS SO FREAKING TOXICCCCC
Awesome article! I disagree with some of these points tho
New idea for your endings, “May The Dark Forest DARKEN Your Path”
But great article! If you do a part 2 some ideas, LionCinder, SparkLark (my opinion on them, YES! Also the couple name RHYMES which makes it even cuter!), IvyFern, and RowanTawny!