Looking for a place to chat about Warriors? You’ve found the right place!
The Sunning Patch is dedicated to talking about the series that has brought us all together. Got some headcanons? Wanna share your favourite character? Comment on this page!
Note: our spoiler rule still applies to this page! If a book in the current arc has released within the past 2 months, keep any comments related to the plot of that book to the book’s spoiler page! Afterwards, you can comment about it here, but make sure to include a spoiler warning! Blurbs can be commented about here, but include a spoiler warning. Nobody likes being spoiled about something they’re looking forward to, after all!
If you’re looking for a place to have more in-depth discussions about Warriors or are looking for a change of pace for Warriors discussion, check out the Elders’ Den!
![[an orange tabby cat sleeps in a flower field]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/cat_grass_flowers_lie_sleep-641380.jpg)
[image description: an orange tabby cat sleeps in a flower field]
/⚠️Spoiler alert for TBC and ASC⚠️/
I have a theory about Frostpaw : what if she is in fact Bristlefrost’s reincarnation? I mean, they both have “frost„ in their name and they have quite a similar appearance and personality… What do you think?
I think that’s a long shot. Bristlefrost and Frostpaw aren’t that similar imo, and you could easily say that any gray cat in the Clans looks like them. Also I don’t at all like the idea of reincarnation in the first place; it was handled really horribly in Cinderheart’s arc and I just don’t think the series needs that.
agreed. Bristlefrost reincarnated would just ruin the whole plot in TBC imo
I like the idea of reincarnation, BUT only in the case of non-villainous characters who never made it to StarClan (lost in TBC in the void). However I def agree with Mallow, Cinderheart’s reincarnation was handled awfully and imo Cinderpelt didn’t need to be reincarnated, or we would have all sorts of reincarnated cats from kittens who died young and every warrior that ever got injured or killed on the Thunderpath and then we have the argument, why isn’t everyone reincarnated?? I don’t like reincarnation unless it is spirits that were lost in TBC like I said. So I partially agree with both of you!
Thanks for reading my warriors rant (:
I don’t think so… The authors said they weren’t going to include any more reincarnation, and the special thing with Cinderheart and Cinderpelt was that Cinderkit was born at the exact second that cinderpelt died, and i dont think that happened with Briss. I think she’s just gone forever and I want it to stay that way
No, I don’t agree. It’s just because I’m pretty sure Frostpaw was a kit before Bristlefrost died, but it’s a good theory!
True. If I remember correctly Frostpaw was born in Lost Stars.
Bristlefrost was an apprentice then, so Frostpaw couldn’t have been her reincarnation.
What is one of your favorite scenes in Warrior Cats and why?
For me, it’s the scene in SkyClan’s Destiny where SkyClan saves the young twoleg who falls into the ravine by leading her twoleg parents back to her. That scene is so cute and heartwarming!!!
I always appreciate humorous scenes, like when Mousefur called a Clan meeting. I also like when two characters are just having a normal conversation without it being highly plot important.
One of my favorite specific scenes was when Alderheart and Needletail found Violetshine and Twigbranch; I just loved their interactions.
Mousefur’s Clan Meeting is without a doubt my favorite scene!! And I liked when Tigerstar died /gen It was interesting since no other leader has been killed that way, and Scourge was such a skilled fighter with so little real practice *ahem reinforced claws*
Yessssssss! I love that scene! Mousefur is da best!
When Graystripe and Firestar met and that scene with Sandstorm, Firestar, and Spottedleaf in Firestar’s Quest.
I loved that too. I always love scenes when compassion triumphs over narrow self interest.
Who else was disappointed that Firestar was the fourth? I wanted Cinderheart to be it!
I think it was a good way to end Firestar’s story. He was definitely worthy of the position- he’d served ThunderClan with nothing but fierce loyalty, courage, determination, and a heart made of gold. While the path he took wasn’t an easy one at first, Firestar’s perseverance, dedication, and bravery proved to be stronger than the mistrust his Clanmates showed him, and with those qualities, this kittypet-born tom showed that it wasn’t ancestry that determined a cat’s worth- it was their actions that would, in the end, forge the cat’s legacy. Firestar’s traits, however, didn’t just affect his own choices- they inspired hope and good in other cats, and it would be his involvement in the prophecy that would give StarClan the strength to fight off the warriors of the Dark Forest.
I completely agree!
Well said
I agree!
Agreed
It was a nice way to wrap up his character arc so I actually liked him being the fourth cat.
I actually liked it it was a good plot, and not to be rude but where did Cinderheart come from?
I thought it was her bc then she wouldn’t think she wasn’t special enough anymore!
ohh I see :3
I didn’t see how any of it was pointing to Firestar in the first place, so I don’t really think there was a different cat that could be the fourth. Maybe Hollyleaf . . .
I was very dissapointed, ngl. DUDE U HAD YOUR CHANCE TO SHINE. A WHOLE SERIES!!!!! And it felt like he just barged in on the main plot of series 3 to me, im sorry, thats just me.
Yeah same, he already got the spotlight, other cats deserve it now!
Agreed
Yeah I wanted it to be Ivy but that might have been a bit obvi…
What’s a cat that everybody hates but you secretly love?
Brambleclaw and Dovewing but neither of those are secretly 😛
Brambleclaw or Breezepelt
Not very secret, but Twigbranch. I also like Mudclaw.
Tigerstar 2 but not secretly! And Dovewing!
Star Flower…
not at all secretly and he’s not the MOST hated but Crowfeather.
I also don’t mind Dovewing and twigbranch but I don’t love them either
Leopardstar and Breezepelt
And Goosefeather, Crowfeather and Nightcloud
Dovewing and Crowfeather.
Breezepelt and Nightcloud (and Pinestar and Goosefeather and…
OMG GOOSEFEATHER YUSSSSSS
Clear Sky/Skystar*dodges various flying fruits and some pies in the face*
Splashtail, but only in River – Thunder 😛
Pinestar
twigbranch <33
ashfur
Brambleclaw, Goosefeather, Hawkheart
Thoughts on LeafxCrow? 😀
I like it; their personalities are slightly different, but Leafpool’s kindness and compassion unlocks a more gentle, caring side of Crowfeather that he’d concealed behind his usual cold nature. She helped him out of his grief over the death of Feathertail and let him leave the past behind to move on, and find happiness in his life.
I hate it, it has 0% development, they just randomky go from: ‘Ugh, I hate you!’ to ‘Ah, I love you!’ so it’s totally not realistic. I also love Leafpool and hate Crowfeather and think they’re a terrible match.
I like it :3 but I definitely prefer Feather x Crow!
I agree!
Me too! LeafxCrow… was sad and unhealthy
I like it. It was a bit sudden but they loved each other. It’s tragic how the relationship turned out.
Honestly I’m not a really big fan of it. Crowfeather was like: I love you lets run away together! And when Leafpool accidentally had his kits he didn’t like her anymore. Crowfeather is just an awful mate who CAN’T DECIDE WHO HE LIKES!!! Thank you for listening to my rant
OMG YUSSSSSS, GO MAPEYYY!!!
Do you prefer HeatherxLion or HeatherxBreeze, and why?
Heather x Breeze, I suppose, though I hate Heathertail so I don’t really care about her ships that much. Heather x Lion is not good, though, I consider it quite toxic
HeatherXBreeze, I think that they are really cute together and a good ship.
HeatherxBreeze! I used to like HeatherxLion, but after what had happened between those two, I no longer ship it. Besides, I really loved Heathertail’s support for Breezepelt in one of the hardest times of his life, and the way he showed his more gentle, courageous side after his mate’s kindness and compassion <3
HeatherxBreeze. For one instance, Heathertail helped keep Breezepelt from becoming a villain and they’re perfect for eachother. And HeatherxLion was just a childhood crush between the two.
HeatherBreeze, Lionblaze and Heathertail were just a teenage crush imo. Breeze pet had a more caring and devoted relationship with Heathertail.
I love lionblaze! I think he is trying to control his aggression and he is a great father! What is the main reason y’all don’t like him?
Remember to hit the reply button ^^ I don’t like Lionblaze, mostly because of his needless aggression and tendency to think with his claws, as well as his actions towards cats like Heathertail and Shadowsight. You have good points, though, and your reasons for liking Lionblaze are perfectly valid <3
He’s kind of brainless sometimes😛 But I think he’s pretty cool!
Also, Shyshell, do you want to be my mentor?
he’s pretty boring in pot and oots, jayfeather/hollyleaf/ivypool/dovewing are just so much more interesting, story/character-wise. i feel like if they focused on lionblaze in a book just about him, he would be so much more interesting and compelling as character :/
after pot and oots, he’s so boring ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ he’s just not my type of character imo I’m a jayfeather girly 😛
dang i just re-read power of Three and the omen of the stars and leafpool…
when did she get so mean ToT i mean like, its definitely not just jay’s perspective, shes very stubborn with everyone, it just feels so odd!!
i have no idea why, but i always felt like she was just a nice little girlie and i feel like the fandom treats her like just a tragic character (which she totally is) but she’s just so… MEAN idk
does anyone even get that from the books or am i crazy ToT
edit: :000 page flippo!!!
It’s been a while since I’ve read Power of Three, but I think the reason behind the way Leafpool behaved towards Jayfeather was because she didn’t want him to suspect anything about his true parentage, and no matter how much she wanted to, she had to act like he was just her apprentice, not her son.
Ooohh that makes a lot of sense!!! That’s such a reasonable headcanon :0
Agreed, I’ve always thought about it that way.
yes, that’s probably it or at least part of it :))
Omg that makes so much sense suddenly… I forgot that Leafpool was Jay’s mother
Not related but hi other rainbow! I actually used to be named rainbowshine, but then i found out that you were also rainbowshine so i changed it to rainbowflower. But yea, sorry for this not being related to ur comment! 😅
Hello fellow Rainbowpaw 😀 that’s so funny omg I knew there was another Rainbowpaw but I didn’t know you used to be Rainbowshine!! Honestly, Rainbowflower is such a cuter name though <333 nice to meet you :))
Nice to meet you too! Im pretty sure we are blog sibs, right? Correct me if im wrong lol
I don’t think we are yet, but I’d love to be 😀
Cool!
Yeah, I think she was just scared bc of cats finding out she had kits or smth TvT
Rank the below characters from favorite to least favorite, and give reasons for your choices.
Breezepelt, Cinderheart, Bluestar, Goosefeather, Heathertail, Hollyleaf
Here’s mine:
1. Heathertail
As my 4th favorite character, Heathertail rests on number one on this list due to her kindness, positivity, and her friendliness towards everyone.
2. Breezepelt
Breezepelt has climbed to my ‘like’ side after his redemption, and for that, and his journey, especially in Crowfeather’s Trial, has made him the second place here.
3. Bluestar
My view on her shifted a bit and moved her down towards a more of a dislike after I reflected on her many bad choices, including her slight mistreatment towards apprentices and her renaming of Brightpaw.
4. Cinderheart
In my opinion, Cinderheart was a whiny drama queen for the most of OotS, constantly thinking she wasn’t special enough, and when she finds out she is, she whines and whines about who she should be, until Lionblaze smacks some sense into her.
5. Hollyleaf
Hollyleaf was okay at first, though her obsession with the warrior code honestly got on my nerves so badly. But later, when she finds out about her heritage, she gets mad at Squirrelflight, despite her saving Hollyleaf from Ashfur. Her ungratefulness irks me and results in her placement as one of my least favorites.
6. Goosefeather
Goosefeather is my very least favorite character. Throughout his life, he did many cruel acts, such as permanently injuring a kit, ignoring a cat in need despite his duties as a medicine cat, and urging Bluefur to give up her very young kits just to replace Thistleclaw as deputy, even though Goosefeather could have just solved the problem himself by telling.
That’s it; I can’t wait to see your rankings of these characters 😀
1. Hollyleaf!
I ADORE this girly! She’s smart, a girlboss and one of the only people that follows the Warrior Code! I headcanon she has a mental disorder, which makes her extra cool, since she would be the second cat with one, and it’d be relatable for people who have a mental disorder too! HOLLYLEAF IS SO SLAYYYYYY
2. Bluestar!
She’s super cool! I love Bluestar bc she’s one of the only leaders that didn’t totally get a new personality when she became one! I love how she always does what she thinks is right, and she was also a very goof aunt to Whitestorm! Go Bluestar!
3. Goosefeather
He’s cool! I LOVE his novella, his power is so interesting! And Stormtail is a total dung-face! I just like Goosefeather bc he is very weird, and weird characters are the coolest😛
4. Cinderheart
She’s kinda nice, but to me she feels like just a bland copy of Cinderpelt, and kinda boring.
5. Breezepelt
He’s very annoying, but at least he hates Crowfeather too.
6. Heathertail
UgGgGgGgh!!! I hate her! She’s just SO childish and dumb and annoying! Just ugh!
ahhhhh I can’t remember but which kit did he permanently injure T0T
He injured Crookedstar, that makes me hate him even more tho.
1. Hollyleaf my baby
Hollyleaf did not deserve to get left out of the prophecy and she did everyone a favor by killing Ashfur. My baby deserves better.
2. Bluestar
Bluestar’s Prophecy is my fav super edition and I love how Sunstar helps her handle her grief. Overall Bluestar is great and I love her she’s so buff
3. Heathertail
I loved Heathertail up until BadBreezyBoi. He makes me SO mad. More on that later. Anyway… HeatherxLion is one of my top three favorite ships so I love Heathertail!! (gonna ignore the fact that she’s old enough to be Breezepelt’s mother)
4. Cinderheart
I hate the whole reincarnation thing with a passion and Cinderheart deserved better. But it’s not Cinderheart’s fault. Once she and Lionblaze got together I live laugh love their relationship because they actually fight like a real couple and it’s a realistic relationship
5. Goosefeather
In summary: prophecy man
He does some wierd things and really no one should have trusted his omens as he got older, like the battle where Moonflower died with the “flattened fur”. So I’m not sure if everything was his fault because StarClan cursed him for no reason and his Clanmates shouldn’t have believed him while he was old lazy and insane.
6. Bad Boi Bad Boi
Do I really need to explain myself???
Breezepelt makes me so mad. Wolfshine, I respect your opinion but I completey disagree on this one. He has had no redemption whatsoever, and just because he hasn’t done anything evil lately, he certainly hasnt done anything good either.
1. Hollyleaf. She’s the one who annoys me the least and is generally a flawed but unique character who really has her own personality and sticks with it for the majority of her time as a character. She develops nicely and learns from her mistakes, and while she can be a bit irritating she is definitely entertaining to read about and will keep you guessing for a bit.
2. Goosefeather. Another uniquely flawed character, he’s definitely not the best acting guy and gives senile vibes for sure, but he’s interesting and it’s always fun to see how interprets prophecies and other things. He’s done many irredeemable things, but he’s not quite a villain, and such a morally gray character holds a place in my heart.
3. Cinderheart. She’s kind, thoughtful, and a great friend to Hollyleaf for the most part. Her identity crisis is realistic and though her struggles with Lionblaze can get annoying (which is why she’s lower on the list) I still find her likable and fun and I enjoy reading about her.
4. Bluestar. I don’t really have much to say about her, but she’s okay enough that I won’t put her at the bottom and eh enough that she’s down here. Basically it.
5. Breezepelt is a fine character. He’s actually not that annoying, the part that sticks with me is just the amount of evil he was before. Trying to kill Poppyfrost (a pregnant cat) and Jayfeather (a blind cat) out of cold blood is disgusting and I can’t forget that.
6. Heathertail. I’ve always hated her character, and I don’t think I’ll ever stop. I’m not shaming all of those who love her, you can like who you like, I just see her as an unimaginative, pessimistic cat who was very unfair to Lionblaze as an apprentice. Though she did such things when she was young, I’ve never really been able to get over it. I guess the Heather x Breeze ship has only worsened it for me, given I dislike both of them.
Our charts are the exact opposite way 😛
1 Sandstorm
She’s really supportive to Firestar, and amazing mother who supports her daughters, a loyal Clanmate, and I can read the part where she insulted Firepaw a million times without getting bored.
2 Twigbranch
She has every right to not want kits!!! She’s a friendly Clanmate and will do anything for her Clan. She always does what she thinks is right even though sometimes it leads to her being an apprentice forever. And she’s just AMAZING!!!
3 Mudclaw
I just like him better than Onestar. He’s also devoted to his Clan and would do the EXACT SAME THING during his leadership if he did become leader as Onestar did during his.
4 Violetshine
She’s amazing and is a great warrior, but I’m not a big fan of the TreexViolet ship. It was definitely rushed and they are nothing like each other.
5 Squirrelflight
She’s great as an apprentice, but as warrior and deputy, she’s always arguing with Bramblestar and she was awful to Nightheart!!!
6 Bramblestar/Ashfur
They are the most annoying cats in the history of warriors!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ashfur just let go of Squirrelflight! She doesn’t like you, get over it!!! BramblestarxSquirrelflight just isn’t working and Bramblestar is a very bad leader.
Thank you for your time.
1. Hollyleaf
Hollyleaf has been one of my favorites since day one, with her determination to do the right thing and her loyalty to her Clan. Although she’s not a very relatable character for the most part, I can mostly understand her motives and the reasons behind her actions, as well as her mental breakdown upon finding out the truth.
2. Bluestar
Bluestar’s life had been scarred by tragedy, but that didn’t stop her from serving her Clan with loyalty, courage, and nobility. In the end, her last life was spent on saving ThunderClan from the dog pack, showing what a great cat she was.
3. Heathertail
Throughout the story, Heathertail has been a character who really stood out to me. From the beginning, she was friendly, mischievous, and feisty, whose decisions led to a certain degree of heartbreak, but later, she grew to become a more levelheaded cat. Her personality has been pretty relatable to me, and I’ve also really liked her romance with Breezepelt.
4. Cinderheart
While I disliked the reincarnation part, I really like Cinderheart’s character. As an apprentice, she displayed a courageous, impulsive, and lively personality, and, like Cinderpelt, she showed a determination that led her to never give up, no matter what.
5. Breezepelt
Breezepelt is a character I like, but his actions prior to his redemption were absolutely horrible. Though I believe he’s redeemed, and he’s found a happy life with Heathertail, his earlier choices stopped him from being higher on this list.
6. Goosefeather
I’ve really grown to like him more than I used to after re-reading his novella, and I have to admit, I liked reading about him slipping from the grasp of sanity. He had a tragic childhood, cursed by StarClan, but in his early life, he always tried to do the right thing. I still don’t really like him, though.
1. Hollyleaf
Hollyleaf was one of the most interesting characters in the series, imo. She started out as ambitious, and wanting power in the Clan. She became a medicine cat to do so. It was a nice twist on the usual backstory for why a cat becomes a medicine cat. She eventually formed a loving for rules, and her breakdown in Sunrise when she realized that she represented everything she was against was truly one of the best moments in Warriors. She matured in her novella, and formed a unique relationship with Fallen Leaves, and when she returned to ThunderClan, she was a truly changed cat. She was skilled and calm, unlike the confused, emotional cat she was in Sunrise. She made mistakes, like trying to kill Leafpool, but ultimately she was a complex, good cat.
2. Goosefeather
Goosefeather was truly a tragic tale for me. He was young when he was burdened with prophetic powers, and burdened further with the inability to prevent the future, similar to Cassandra from mythology. I loved reading about him, and it was sad seeing his eventual mental fallout. He did bad things when he wasn’t fully there in his mind, but ultimately I think he was a good cat whose life was ruined by StarClan.
3. Bluestar
I like reading about mental illness, I must admit. I find it intriguing to see the things people will do when they aren’t fully there in their mind. That’s why I like Goosefeather, and Bluestar. Bluestar was a good cat who did the best she could in every choice- although she did make a few mistakes. She was similar to Firestar in her judgement, but unlike him, she made a mistake from time to time. She mistakenly appointed Tigerclaw as her deputy, and became mentally ill when he betrayed her. In her illness, she made awful choices that Firestar had to help fix. But when she died, ultimately I think she was a good cat who was just mentally ill. She was a very well-written character.
4. Heathertail
Heathertail was a decent cat. She has a brief relationship from another Clan, but ultimately settled for her true love, a cat from her Clan. Quite the opposite of Dovewing. I don’t have many strong opinions about her, whether positive or negative.
5. Breezepelt
I don’t like Breezepelt’s ‘redemption’. He tried to murder the pregnant Poppyfrost and openly betrayed his Clan, not showing any regret until it was too late. He wasn’t manipulated or coerced into betraying the Clans; he blatantly followed the Dark Forest cats. And then everyone feels bad for him when his Clanmates rightfully don’t forgive him for his unredeemed crimes. He isn’t a good cat. He hasn’t done much to redeem himself except not do anything bad lately. But I do think he was written better than Cinderheart.
6. Cinderheart
Cinderheart’s entire character arc was an ableist, pointless mess. She was the reincarnation of Cinderpelt, because StarClan thought that Cinderpelt didn’t live her life to the fullest because she was disabled and has to be a medicine cat. Cinderpelt was even shown to be happy with her new life. But the authors went back on that to say that if you are disabled, you can’t live life to the fullest. Cinderheart wasn’t even an interesting character outside of that. Her romance with Lionblaze was quite pointless. And she just faded into the background after OotS. Cinderheart, ultimately, is a character who I believe never had any business existing in the writing.
1. Hollyleaf!
She’s cool idk 😛 I liked her personality and how shes definitely an enneagram type 1 😛
2. Cinderheart
I liked her a LOT more when she was Cinderpaw, and the whole reincarnation thing was a terrible idea, but i like her better than others on this list 😛
3. Breezepelt
I can’t stand him until he grew up in Crowfeather’s Trial. He’s not misunderstood, hes just pretty toxic until then.
4. Heathertail
I’m just totally indifferent to her. I don’t care for her too much but im not gonna waste my energy hating on her
5. Bluestar
I’ve really just never liked her. She was a really bad mom and she wasn’t a great leader either. Also her as a starclan guide is exhausting and she became a massive mary-sue
6. Goosefeather
He’s soooo annoyinggg and also he caused so much pain that he never takes accountability for
I agree with all of these
1. Hollyleaf- I just love her!! I really wish she was in the prophecy….
2. Goosefeather- I know almost everybody hates him but I really love him. He is so different and unique. I see him in a drifferent light.
3. Bluestar- I loved her then hated her and then loved her again. I wish she didn’t turn crazy but before than she was just amazing and an amazing ruler.
4.Cinderpaw- She was better when she was an apprentice. I loved the whole reincarnation thingamabob but other than that I don’t really care about her
5. Breezepelt- He is okay….. I don’t really like him. I only did put him in 4th cuz I have another cat for 5th.
6.Heathertail- She is so boringgggggggg! She was better when she was with Lionpaw and them she just sorta faded for me so… yeah
WE HAVE THE EXACT SAME COMMENT!!!!!!!
Omg yes!! I didn’t copy if thats what you think. I didn’t read the other comments 😛
Nice to have same opinions!
I didn’t think that!
1. Bluestar
I love her, she was the first she-cat I remember in warriors to be verry respected and strong. Most other she-cats in arc one (Excluding Mousefur), all stayed in the nursery and had kits, and were just back round boring she-cats. Bluestar was not like that, yes she had kits, but she handled it in a verry different way. I don’t agree with he choice to give them away, but no cat is perfect, and I still like her and think she is a great character to this day.
2. Hollyleaf
I also really like Hollyleaf, she is kind, and struggles with fairness and judgment. I can easily relate to her, as I am a middle child and am not particularly special. She didn’t get any powers, but still made her own way in the world.
3. Heathertail
I like her for the same reson you do, she is kind and always open to things. I don’t like Breezepelt as much as her, but the fact that she can bond with a cat who try’s to be grumpy and pushes away everyone else proves how kind she is.
4. Cinderheart
I don’t like the whole I am a reincarnation of Cinderpelt thing, but I really like Cinderheart. She had to overcome Cinderpelt and become her own cat, and I think thats cool and also, I like her relation with Lionblaze. She seems to be so kind and caring. I just don’t like how she faded into the back roundonce she became a mother like so many other cats.
5. Breezepelt
I don’t really like him, he is okay. I feel kinda bad for him, bc his father rejected him. But why’d he have to try to murder Jayfeather for it? Idk, I have mixed feelings about him.
6. Goosefeather
I don’t like him, he was okay as an apprentice, but I think he became a crazy irritating cat. And it wasn’t his fault, he could see dead cats and have visons. But I still don’t like how he told Bluepaw(Star) that she would die in water as a poor apprentice, and how he sent his sister to her death. He also wasn’t a great help to Featherwisker. So, I don’t think he is evil or anything, I just don’t like him.
Sorry that was so long! 😛
Hollyleaf, Goosefeather, Cinderheart, Bluestar, Breezepelt, Heathertail
I’ll give reasons later I’m too lazy 😭
1. breezepelt
I prefer old breezepelt, he commited warcrimes and broke
the Geneva conventionthe warrior code, new team Breezepelt is a Mousefur/Crowfeather/Berrynose character which is less interesting but still probably the most interesting cat on this list.2. bluestar
she goes insane after finding out about the problem of evil paradox, kinda funny ngl
3. hollyleaf
she didn’t have much character dev during x^3 at all but while Jay+Lion were more reactionary, she drove the plot forward
4. heathertail
new team completely transformed her character, she’s also a background character now and we haven’t had a WindClan POV in a while (maybe her rank will change next arc)
5. cinderheart
mary sue, cardboard cutout, revived Cinderpelt for no reason other than nostalgia and she’s as interesting as Lionblaze’s chapters 💀(sorry)
1. Breezepelt, I just love how he does everything, and he was such a great father to his kits.
2. Hollyleaf. She was just so cool, and is just the slayest character ever-
3. Goosefeather. I just want ppl to stop hating on him.
4. Bluestar. She was an amazing leader, right until she thought the whole of her clan was against her *sigh*
5. Cinderheart. She was such a pick me ngl-
6. Heathertail. I just really hate her for how she reacted to Lionblaze saying they couldn’t play anymore
Oof, I don’t have time to do the reasons ;-; (gotta go to school)
1. Breezepelt
2. Bluestar
3. Hollyleaf
4. Heathertail
5. Cinderheart
6. Goosefeather
I hate all of them but here we go
1. Cinderheart! I love any type of supernatural stuff and hence the reincarnation stuff was right down my lane :))
2. Hollyleaf. I didn’t really like her at all but I find her better than most of the other characters on this list.
3. Goosefeather. I haven’t read much of him but what I’ve heard so far is pretty cool
4. Bluestar. I hate her.
5. Heathertail. I really hate her.
6. Breezepelt. He did a ton of bad stuff and didn’t get any sort of punishment, and I find that really unfair for cats like Leafpool, who only did what they thought was best for their clan and then have to plead to get let into StarClan?
K so I’m not doing Goosefeather bc I don’t know him
1. Hollyleaf
One of my fave cats, no question. Her death tho….made me tear up. Revive hollyleaf, StarClan, plsssss! She’s just so amazing! I ship her with Cinderheart. Hollyleaf is so brave and kind, and she honestly would have made a great leader in my opinion.
2. Bluestar
I know she’s frequently hated on for what she did, but it wasn’t her fault. She was going through such a hard time, and she really needed support, but she didn’t have anyone to support her. Other than that, she was so noble and brave and awesome, and I honestly love her! She was graceful, yet adventurous, and so just awesome! Yah, I honestly just love her.
3. Cinderheart
She’s pretty great! Honestly she’s just a good character, but the reason she’s not higher on the list is the drama with Lionblaze. Like sure there’s a prophecy, but y’all could still be together! Other than that, she’s great!
4. Heathertail
She was great as a ‘paw, but she was SUCH a jerk to Lionblaze! I love apprentice Heathertail, but warrior Heathertail is such a diva. Like chill out girl!
5. The rat “Breezepelt”
I literally don’t think he even deserves a name. Breezepelt is literally my least favorite character IN THE ENTIRE SERIES. Rat is the perfect word to describe this freaking jerk. I’ve seen him be nice to ONE character. ONE TIME. AND IT WAS HIS MOM! And he’s just a rat to everyone else. I HATE him so much!!! StarClan, kill Breezepelt. Kill Breezepelt, please!
1. Breezepelt
I liked his redemption arc and him as a villain was pretty good too
2. Hollyleaf
She was mid for a while. She was way better when she came back from the tunnels and I’m glad she saved Ivypool’s life.
3. Cinderheart
Mid, was kinda whiny about not being special or whatever, other than that she was fine
4. Heathertail
She annoyed me so much as an apprentice oh my gosh XD she’s way better now that she’s a warrior, though! Another mid cat
5. Bluestar
I despise her lol
She’s honestly kind of stupid – literally just tell Sunstar that Thistleclaw is bad! Literally tell him to choose anyone but him, ok? Also, there was no for-sure he was gonna choose Thistleclaw. Also, moving your like 2-moon old kits across the territory in a blizzard?? I’m sorry what?? And her decline in mental stability towards the end of her life is also negative points. Her treatment of Brightheart was unacceptable.
6. Goosefeather
Pretty much the same reasons you said lol
Who ever puts Bluestar in last or 2nd to last HOW DARE YOU!!!Bc:
BLUESTAR 4 LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sorry I overreacted a little…😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Yessssssss! I agree!
agreed >:3
Disagree I don’t hate her she’s just… ehhhhhh a bit crazy after the Tigerclaw thing went down, she could’ve handled it better, and her reaction ultimately led to the death of an apprentice and severe internal as well as external scarring to another.
Fireheart did warn her about Tigerclaw, but she seemed to ignore/chose not to listen to his suspicions. I agree she could have handled it better.
I put Bluestar 2nd, lol
disagreed :p
Me: *reads random WC book*
Mousefur: smth blah blah blah winter smth
Me: WINTER?! WHAT?
Lol I think I remember that xD
How did I not see this!!! Warrior cats do know what humans call leaf-bare!
Which book was it?
Wait what? 😛
Lol XD
hahahahahaha
Ikr how WC just randomly know what winter is
What happens if a leader dies of old age would starclan heal that as well?
Yes
I don’t think leaders can die of old age…
they can :p
It has never happened tho, so how can you know they can?
I think Tallstar died of old age, correct me if I’m wrong
I think he had trouble breathing, but it was probably old age
yes and also… *spoiler for ASC*
Oh yeah, but they kind of just collapsed, plus they were on their last life anyways, so they would’ve gone to StarClan either way.
it happened to tallstar, blackstar, and mistystar
Blackstar drowned.
oh shoot, really? i must be misremembering the mention in bramblestar’s storm. thanks lol
Tallstar, Leopardstar, and Mistystar. The books said that Leopardstar died from sickness, but that could’ve been because of old age.
This is a question that would be interesting to explore in the books. How would old age be healed?
My guess is that it counts as an unstoppable death for leaders, and they lose all their lives to it.
I think that they would go to StarClan, recieve their next life and come back the same. It depends on how old age killed them, though. If it were some illness or heart attack or something like that, they’d probably just descend to StarClan, but if it was just because they were old, I’d think they’d come back and live their next life/lives.
I actually think the opposite would be true. If the cat died of a heart attack or age-related illness, I think that they would come back and live their next life. But if they just deteriorated with age and could hardly do anything, I think they would lose all their lives.
Illness, yes, they would probably return, but if they had a heart attack (or something related to that) then their heart would stop working and I think that would be out of StarClan’s healing powers. I agree with the last one, though.
I think I know how. In the books, cats in Starclan are always young, fit, just like they were when they were young. So my guess is that they can die from old age but they come back not old and tired but young and healthy.
I think cats in StarClan look the age they were happiest at. For example, Yellowfang might look old in StarClan.
my theory is that they can only die of old age on their last life, which is how mistystar lived so long
do I have any proof? not really. I don’t care lol
Yeah, I think that too.
Makes sense to me.
This is
Good question! I don’t really know what would happen when it would come to that. I’d think StarClan would give them another life, but I’m not really sure.
Well nobody really “dies of old age”, you get weaker as you become old and as you get weaker, you die from other complications. Starclan would probably heal that but after reviving, the leader would probably die soon after because the complications wont disappear so it would be overall ineffective.
Yes? It doesn’t happen a lot, though, even for normal warriors.
I think I remember a StarClan cat (or a random Vicky post) stated that any StarClan cat can look like what they looked like during the happiest time of their life/the part of life they thought they looked best in and stayed like that, I think it was like that for Tallstar since he wasn’t old in StarClan, so yes, they can be healed!!
Stick has it’s own Wiki page! :0 JayXStick <3333
https://warriors.fandom.com/wiki/Jayfeather's_stick?so=search
Yayyay stick!!!!
Whyyyyyyyy, HE’S A STICK PPL HE DOESN’T BREATHE AND STUFF😛 But fr, why does he have a wiki page???????
Omg that’s hilarious xD
JayXStick forever 😛
:00
Jayfeather’s stick is a big,[1] long,[6] smooth,[4] slender,[7] and pale[8] piece of wood.[4] The bark is stripped off of it,[4] and it is scarred[9] and notched[10] in many places. Prior to The Fourth Apprentice, the stick was one whole piece. However, Jayfeather snapped it in half due to being angry with Rock.[2]
😂
lol XD good for stick 😛
Yes! LOl!
Wow! I didn’t know that it was so popular that it got a wiki page….
STICK SUPREMACY