1,050 comments

  • Great book! I can’t help but think Darktail is a Skyclan descendant trying to take revenge on Skyclan and the other clans.

  • The only problem with this book, is I couldn’t reD IT UNTIL AFTER I read TAS Sooooo… I had a LOT of spoilers. AND a theory about Violet and Twig.

    • I read this book after TAS. It came out after TAS so a lot of people read TAS before it. And is your theory that Hawk and Pebble are their parents? Because that’s basically confirmed. (Well not really but very heavily implied. 😜)

  • Some things I suspect:
    “The spark that remains” is Sparkpelt
    “Embrace what you find in the shadows, for only it can clear the sky” (or something like that) means that SkyClan has to find Violetpaw
    The grey kit Echosong sees could be Twigpaw
    There is a chance that Twigpaw and Violetpaw could be Mintfur’s kits or Barley and Cloudmist’s (Idk how I came up with that one)
    Cherrytail will die soon
    If SkyClan would have never been drove out, Bouncefire would eventully become deputy.
    Hawkwing will choose Sagenose, Sandynose, or Sparrowpelt to be deputy if he becomes leader.
    If Sandynose never returned, Plumwillow and Hawkwing would become mates later in life.
    Pebbleshine was killed trying to get prey on the Thunderpath for her kits.

    Now that I look, that is alot!!! 😛

  • Warrior with hawks wings-Echosong
    Loved that quote. Hawkwing I hope you find your daughter

  • Ugh, poor Hawkwing. Everything has to happen to him.

    First, his brother dies. Then his father dies. Then his mother and sister decide to stay with Barley. And his mate gets kidnapped by Twolegs. What else?

  • I really enjoyed Hawkwings journey but I found some parts rushed and some pets were hard to follow. What is your personal opinion on this book and what do you think was very well and what waS not so great?

  • My theories:

    Violetpaw and Twigpaw are Pebbleshine’s kits

    Hawkwing will be a major part in the battles against Darktail

    Violetpaw and Twigpaw are truly SkyClan cats and will live with SkyClan when they reach the lake

    SkyClan will reach the lake in Shattered Sky

    Leafstar will die by the end of VoS and Hawkwing will be the long lasting leader of SkyClan

    • 1. I think that was largely hinted at by the Erins, so hopefully it becomes canon!
      2. And maybe we’ll get another POV from him, if we’re lucky. 😀
      3. I can’t see it happening with Twigpaw. She’s grown on ThunderClan too much, and as for Violetpaw, eh… a possibility, perhaps… but probably not.
      4. Yes, yes, yes, yes!!!!!!!!!! I’ve been waiting on this. :DDD
      5. Maybe in the fifth book, or late fourth… seems like it’d be the right timing. (Just a guess though)

    • 1. Yep!
      2. Not sure.
      3. I think they’ll join SkyClan as well.
      4. Yep!
      5. Well, she probably will die this series. We just have to wait and see.

  • Kate, will we ever know what happened to Fidgetpaw, Waspwhisker and the others that were taken in the upcoming books.

  • Cake, I know i will probably get a W.A.S for this, but Can you give us hints to the Doveheart SE?

  • I want characters who stayed behind or were taken to come back because i feel bad them being seperated. I know not all of them can come back though. The kittypets probably wont but idk.

      • Hopefully Twigpaw and Violetpaw are his kits. Just imagine his reaction when he sees them if they are😊 Pebbleshine!!!!!😭

          • I bet when they hear what Darktail did to Hawkwing and SkyClan a good number of ShadowClan-rogues (hopefully including Violetpaw) will leave 😛

              • I don’t know… she knows Twigpaw is alive and living with ThunderClan, but she hasn’t left for her sister.

              • Excuse me? I’m not doing anything to Violetpaw… I want her to leave Darktail’s group because they are murderers who hate the Clans and will do anything to destroy them, and prophecied cat or not, she’s young and goodhearted and doesn’t deserve to fight the Clans who nurtured her. She shouldn’t have to fight Twigpaw/Hawkwing/Pebbleshine/Lilyheart/Rowanstar/Tawnypelt/Tigerheart/any of the other Clan cats.

          • That, I guess, is part of the reason why Shattered Sky might be heart-breaking 🙈 I mean, to read VIoletkit fighting for Needletail or even Darktail against… well… maybe Hawkwing 🙈

Latest Art

More BlogClan Art