![[image description: Ashfur's face floats above Rootspring and Willowshine walking in the Dark Forest]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/EYkhZSMXkAIvfWO.jpg)
Official spoiler page for The Broken Code #5: The Place of No Stars.
It’s here! This page will remain a discussion page until we get closer to the release date and/or Darkness Within is released. Have fun!
October 20, 2020: Some people got a little impatient, so I went ahead and changed this to a spoiler page. Happy discussing!
Thank you so much to everyone who participated in this year’s gift exchange! As always, your creations were absolutely wonderful and you never fail to blow me away with your talent and creativity! To find your name in...
Okay, so this post is a little later than what I would’ve wanted, but I’ve had a busy week 😛 I’m also a little tired, so, only one cat pic this time 😛 You’re getting plenty from Cadvent, anyway...
The seventh edition of the Blog Monthly is here – written by Lil, fresh off the printing press Hello, everyone!! The Blog Monthly is back and better than ever! I hope you all love this edition, in my opinion it is one...
![[Ashfur joyfully looks at Squirrelflight who is grinning at him]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/squirrelflight-ashfur-ginjaninjaowo.jpg)
Sliverthorn argues why Ashfur would’ve been better for Squirrelflight than Brambleclaw.
![[Ivypool looks out from amidst the forest's ground foliage]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/ivypool-385x300.jpg)
Goldenfawn
🤍🪷 Lilybreeze 🪷🤍
✧˖°🍾⋆˙⟡ pineblossom (she/her) 🦢💫🩰 what are you doing new year's eve? 🌨️🧸🕯️mentor to skyshimmer! 🌲⋆✴︎˚｡⋆
Fan Articles
⨺⃝🏳️🌈🏴☠️Jasminepaw/song the Pirate Queen🏴☠️ Jaz, Jazzy, Sienna⨺⃝
Is it just me or do I always come up for a theme song of music I listen to for each book of TBC arc? 🤔 The theme song for this book for example (to me) is Let It Happen-Tame Impala
Good choice of music! 😀 I love Tame Impala!
I sometimes like matching songs to certain books, events and characters in Warriors, so you’re not alone there! 😉
Yay!!! ^w^
OOOH OOH OOH OOH OOH OOH OOH OOH OOH OOH OOH
Ok so the imposter is definitely Ashfur yeah, but look how epic this cover is.
A pissed cat! How could you go wrong? 😉
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS I LOVE THE DARK FOREST!!!!!!!!!!!!! (wow, that sounds really dark……….but I do enjoy it very much 😛 )
I kinda like it too thunderclan is too perfect
Exactly! Glad they showed the pov’s of other clans in this chapter. But sadly Riverclan and Windclan didn’t get an important character this series
What about Pinestar, Tigerclaw, Thistleclaw, and Ashfur?
I would say that ThunderClan has some imperfect characters, but that they consider themselves as “the perfect Clan that can do no wrong” in my opinion!
Quick question. Has anyone else noticed that nearly every main character is related to Firestar!!! (Excluding DOTC.) Squirrelflight and Leafpool are his daughters, and Bramblestar is eventually his son-in-law. Besides, Stormfur is his best friends son. Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, Dovewing? I don’t even have to say it! Alderheart is his grandson, Bristlefrost is his great-great-great niece, and Shadowsight is his great-great-great nephew! (Ha! I bet you didn’t think of Shadowsight!)
How is Shadowsight related to Firestar again? Is it Dovewing? And remind me, who are Dovewing and Ivypool’s parents? Warriors family tree is so big sometimes I have trouble wrapping my head around it.
Firestar’s sister Princess > Cloudtail > Whitewing > Dovewing > Shadowsight
Dovewing and Ivypool’s parents are Whitewing and Birchfall! ;D
Oh, ok, thanks. BTW, I changed my name to I CAN’T WAIT FOR PLACE OF NO STARS!!!
Yes, I see that! 😛
😛
what about rootspring!
Rootspring – Violetshine – Twigbranch – foster father (Snowbush) – Cloudtail- no need to explain
Stormfur is also Firestar’s mate’s (Sandstorm) Cousin’s (Graystripe, yes. Willowpelt’s brother is Redtail, also Sandstorm’s father.) Son (Stormfur),
I LOVE the red! It’s so cool!
Ik but it tells you that a beloved cat will die 🙁
If it is Squirrelflight I will cry for a week.
I’ll cry for a month 😛 And I almost never cry while reading books, so that’s saying something.
I absolutely never cry when it comes to books and tv shows. It’s pretty sad. I have a friend that’s exactly like that, and then my other friend cries at pretty much all sad books.
Me too
I am so with you!!!!! If Squirrelflight dies, I think I might literally sue the Erin hunter team!
i havent read the books in years but if it is squirrelflight i’ll cry too tbh
DON’T SAY THAT! SQUIRRELFLIGHT CAN’T DIE! THAT’D JUST BREAK MY HEART 🙁
Everyone dies eventually, so if it’s not now, it’s going to be sometime later 😛
rip
spottedleaf
I cried when Briarlight died, I will cry if Squirrelflight, Jayfeather or Lionblaze dies too!!! 🙁
I really want Squirrelstar! Let her be like Mistystar, and kill her off later!
She needs to become leader.
It does? Where?
It does? Where? I hope not Squirrelflight!
Where does it say that?
WhAt OtHeR wArRiOrS vIlLiAnS aRe GrAy WiTh BlUe EyEs?
NO MY ASHFUR IS NOT A VILLAIN
Sorry to break it to you, but signs point to Ashfur 😛
*DARKNESS WITHIN SPOILER ALERT IF YOU HAVE NOT READ DARKNESS WITHIN AND DON’T WANT SPOILERS ABOUT THE IMPOSTOR, DON’T READ AHEAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*
Don’t say I didn’t warn you
Ashfur is the impostor
Goosefeather? It could be him, although all signs are pointing to Ashfur.
GOOSEFEATHER WAS NOT A VILLAIN HE WAS MISUNDERSTOOD AND WAS ONE OF THE BEST CHARACTERS IN THE SERIES
If it was from that period of time, Stormtail would be a better choice in my opinion.
Are you sure? 😉
How could it be Goosefeather?
Cause he is mean! Remember what he did to poor Stormkit?
YES YES YES YEEEEEEEES
I really didn’t want Ashfur to be the villain
me too, I love him 🙁
I kind of do, since it makes sense. I don’t know why.
I don’t think he is fit to be a huge villain, but not a good guy either.
I was hoping it would someone no one was expecting 😛
Yeah same. I tried to make the fire reference a villain would say other than the fire that Ashfur made,
Maybe it could be one of stormfur’s tribe relatives who feels detached from the Tribe of EH and is bullied and misunderstood because of that!
WE HAVE THE BLURB!! CHECK THE OFFICIAL WARRIORS WEBSITE FOR IT!!!
I KNOW! I KNOW! I KNOW! Yay, blurb!
yep. The impostor’s definitely Ashfur.
i think the red is so cool!
Everyone needs to remember that this imposter came from StarClan, so it could be any angry gray tom with blue eyes. Plus, I’m pretty sure Kate said it would be someone we’d never expect. It seems like everyone expects Ashfur.
I am giving credit to Bright Guardian Akira for the Ashfur theory! I wouldn’t have thought of it at first if it weren’t for his videos…
I know right!
You also need to remember that all the in-book signs: the imposter’s obsession with Squirrelflight, loneliness/depression without her, snarky remarks to Squirrelflight, and much more, point to mainly if not only Ashfur. And now a cat who exactly matches his description shows up on TBC 5 cover. Chances are close to 0% it’s some other gray cat with blue eyes if all the other evidence only points to one gray cat with blue eyes named Ashfur.
I am sorry if you don’t want it to be him, but please don’t start ignoring facts and evidence and Ashfur’s history only because you want the imposter to be someone else
Kate said “a controversial character would be returning”, she never said the imposter would be someone we didn’t expect
I just had an unexpected thought. And remember this is just a thought, so don’t kill me:
What if the cat is Stonefur? If you remember in The Prophecies Begin, he was a little reluctant to forgive Bluestar. It’s unexpected, and Stonefur might’ve held a grudge against ThunderClan because Bluestar have him up, and ShadowClan because Blackstar killed him. Also, Stonefur matches the cover of the book exactly. He’s in StarClan, too.
Please do not kill me for this. *dodges angry cat*
I mean, I will tell you a whole bunch of reasons why Stonefur is a good cat (he literally gave his life for the kits) but I’m surge you already know. I don’t think that he will be attracted to Squirrelflight in any way. But what color is his eyes?
His eyes are Blue. Like Bluestars. But remember, this comment was just a random thought i had.
It seems to make more sense that it is Ashfur. If you compare the Ashfur on this cover to the Ashfur on the old Long Shadows cover, they are identical
Yeah, I agree!
One of Stonefur’s Ancient ancestors who saw Squirrelflight and got a crush on her? Plus hates one of Squirrelflights ancestors for leaving around DoTC?